Can you ask an eleven plus child a question if you are not
completely sure that you know the `correct’ answer? If the question appears on
an established eleven plus paper or in a school text book, and seems to be reasonably
genuine, then it may, sometimes, take courage to question the answer.
Suppose you ask: `What is the opposite of white?’ Then your bright,
alive and an alert eleven plus child should know the answer. If it looks as if
there may be more than one reasonable answer - then there may be a case for concern.
In some of our centres we are offering children wider and
different comprehension passages to work through. This is because some children
will meet questions in the eleven plus examination where they have to read
short passages and supply the answers. Text book type answers are required in the
examination. These are answers where there is a right and a wrong. We are
meeting, however, bright children who appear to prefer to adapt or embellish
the answer. These are children who are used to thinking and reasoning. Perhaps they
are even children who have been taught at school and at home to think and to
question?
In some questions children may be asked to explain the meaning.
The questions will probably start with the words: “Explain the meaning” or “What
does the writer mean by?” Parts of the eleven plus have for a long time been
dependent on vocabulary. Some children may not need a wide vocabulary to be
able to come up with a plausible answer!
Sometimes it may be possible to emerge with a plausible answer
even if the phrase or question is not clear. If the question asks the reader to
refer to something in the passage then finding the answer may be reasonably
straight forward. If, however, the questions asks for an explanation of a
relationship between two passages or events then different parts of the passage
may have to be understood and
appreciated.
No comments:
Post a Comment